When your parent needs help at home, one of the first big choices is whether to hire through an agency or find a caregiver on your own. Both paths can work, but they carry very different risks and responsibilities. This guide to the home care agency vs private caregiver decision is for Indianapolis families who want to compare safety, cost and day-to-day hassle before they hire.
Key takeaways
- An agency handles screening, training, supervision, payroll and backup caregivers for you.
- Hiring privately can give you more direct control, but you take on the employer’s duties and risks.
- When you hire privately, you may owe household employment taxes and need to think about insurance.
- The right choice depends on your parent’s needs, your time and how much risk you can accept.
What each option really means
When you hire through a home care agency, the agency employs the caregiver. It finds, screens, trains and pays them, and it is responsible for supervising their work. You work with the agency on a care plan and schedule.
When you hire a private caregiver, sometimes called an independent caregiver, you usually find the person yourself through word of mouth, online ads or a matching website. In most cases, you or your parent become the employer. That means you set the pay, handle the schedule and are responsible for what goes wrong.
Home care agency vs private caregiver: side by side
Here is a simple comparison of the areas families tend to care about most.
| Area | Through an agency | Private caregiver |
|---|---|---|
| Background checks | Done by the agency | Your responsibility |
| Training | Agency trains and checks skills | Depends on the person |
| Supervision | Often overseen by a nurse or care manager | You supervise |
| Sick days and vacations | Agency sends a backup caregiver | You find coverage or go without |
| Payroll and taxes | Agency handles them | You may be a household employer |
| Insurance | Agency carries liability and workers’ coverage | Check your own insurance |
| Hourly rate | Usually higher | Often lower |
| Control over choice of caregiver | You can request a change | You choose directly |
Benefits of hiring through an agency
The main benefit of an agency is that you are not on your own. If a caregiver calls in sick at 6am, the agency is responsible for finding someone else. If there is a problem with care, you have a supervisor to call.
- Screening and checks: Agencies run background checks and verify references before a caregiver enters your parent’s home.
- Licensing: In Indiana, home care and home health agencies are licensed through the Indiana Department of Health, which sets rules they must follow.
- Care planning: A good agency builds a written plan of care and updates it as needs change.
- Fewer legal and tax duties: The agency handles payroll, tax withholding and insurance.
- More skills on call: If your parent’s needs grow, an agency may be able to add personal care, home health or overnight care.
Risks of hiring a private caregiver
Many families find wonderful private caregivers, and the lower hourly rate can be appealing. Still, it is worth being clear about the risks before you hire.
No backup coverage
One caregiver means one point of failure. If they get sick, quit or take a trip, you may suddenly need to cover shifts yourself or leave your parent alone.
You may become an employer
According to the IRS, if you pay a household worker above a certain amount in a year, you may need to withhold and pay Social Security and Medicare taxes, and possibly federal unemployment tax. The IRS explains these rules in Publication 926. Indiana may also have state tax duties. Talk to a tax professional before you start paying someone directly.
Insurance and injury
If a private caregiver is hurt while lifting your parent or slipping on an icy step, you may be responsible. Check with your homeowners or renters insurance agent about what is covered.
Safety and trust
Without professional screening and supervision, it can be harder to spot problems early. Older adults can be targets of financial exploitation, so keep bank cards, checks and valuables secure no matter who you hire. Agencies are not perfect either, but they add another layer of oversight.
Questions to ask before you decide
- How many hours of care does your parent need each week?
- Who will cover if the caregiver is sick or on vacation?
- Do you have time to manage payroll, taxes and scheduling?
- Does your parent have medical needs that call for nurse oversight?
- How will you check the quality of care when you are not there?
If you lean toward an agency, our guide on how to choose the right home care provider lists the questions to ask during your first call. For budgeting, our post on home care costs in Indianapolis explains what affects the price.
How Aken can help Indianapolis families
Aken Home Health and Home Care is a Registered Nurse-led agency, so a nurse is involved in assessing your parent, building the care plan and overseeing caregivers. We handle screening, training, scheduling and backup coverage, so you can focus on being a son, daughter or spouse again.
- Personal care assistance for bathing, dressing and mobility
- Companion care for company, supervision and errands
- Home health services such as skilled nursing when a doctor orders them
We serve Indianapolis and nearby communities including Carmel, Fishers, Zionsville, Avon, Brownsburg, Plainfield and Greenwood. Learn more about Aken and our approach.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to hire a private caregiver?
The hourly rate is often lower, but it may not include taxes, insurance, background checks or the cost of missed shifts. When you add those up, the gap can be smaller than it first looks.
Do I have to pay taxes if I hire a caregiver directly?
You may. The IRS treats many private caregivers as household employees once pay reaches a certain level in a year. A tax professional can help you understand what applies to your family.
Can Medicaid pay for a private caregiver in Indiana?
Some Indiana Medicaid waiver programs offer options where the participant directs their own care, and in some cases family members can be paid. The rules depend on the program, so ask your care manager or Area Agency on Aging, such as CICOA in Indianapolis.
What should I check before hiring a home care agency?
Confirm the agency is licensed in Indiana, ask how caregivers are screened and trained, and find out who supervises care. Also ask how backup coverage works and how the agency communicates with families.
Aken Home Health and Home Care is a Registered Nurse-led agency serving Indianapolis and surrounding counties. Call our office at 317-734-3934 (Mon to Fri, 9am to 4pm) or our 24/7 line at 574-320-4705, or request a free consultation.